Plonk Wine Club Vs. Wine Access | Which Club Wins?

Selecting the right wine club can be daunting, with each offering distinct features and advantages. In this article, we'll compare two wine clubs, Plonk Wine Club and Wine Access Wine Club, to help you determine the best fit for your wine preferences and lifestyle. 

Plonk Wine Club: An Overview 

Plonk Wine Club is known for its curated selection of organic, biodynamic, and natural wines from boutique wineries. The club focuses on providing high-quality, unique wines that showcase their terroir and sustainable winemaking practices.

Etty Klein runs Plonk. She has a talent for finding great wines and is a big reason to consider joining this wine club.  Please read our full review of Plonk for more detail.

Key Features 

• A curated selection of organic, biodynamic, and natural wines
• Wines sourced from small boutique wineries worldwide
• Offers a variety of membership options, including red, white, and mixed wine clubs
• Provides detailed tasting notes and food pairing suggestions
• Complimentary shipping on all wine club shipments

Top Wine Club For Organic Wines

Plonk Wine Club

The best natural and organic wines delivered to your door each month.

Pros:

• Organic and Natural Wines
• Wines Curated By Wine Experts
• Flexible Shipping
• Discover New Varietals and Regions

Cons:

• Buying wine directly from Plonk was more expensive than buying the same wine from a local wine store
• Some people don't want natural, organic wines

Click Here To Sign Up Our Review

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Wine Access Wine Club: An Overview 

Wine Access Wine Club is a premium wine subscription service that offers expertly curated, limited-production wines from top wine regions around the globe. The club emphasizes quality, exclusivity, and education, providing members with a refined wine experience. 

There are several different club options. Some options seem to come and go quickly, which we find annoying. The least expensive club is typically around $25 a bottle. While that's not extreme, it ain't cheap either. You should really consider whether you are getting value with this club.

Key Features 

• Expertly curated, limited-production wines from top wine regions
• Access to exclusive, hard-to-find wines
• Offers two membership options: the Discovery Wine Club and the Connoisseur's Wine Club
• Provides in-depth tasting notes, winemaker stories, and educational content
• Shipping is included on orders of six bottles or more.

Wine Access - Highly Coveted Wines, Expertly Curated.

Pros:

• Wine selected by trusted wine experts
• A diverse range of wine clubs to select from
• Customer service is responsive

Cons:

• Themed clubs change often
• Wine is pricier than many clubs

Click Here To Sign Up

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Similarities and Differences 

Similarities 

• Both clubs offer a wide selection of wines from around the world.
• Both provide detailed tasting notes and food pairing suggestions for each wine.
• Both have various membership options, allowing you to choose the frequency and type of wines you receive.

Differences 

• Plonk Wine Club focuses on organic, biodynamic, and natural wines, while Wine Access Wine Club offers limited-production, exclusive wines.
• Plonk sources its wines from small, boutique wineries, while Wine Access focuses on premium, hard-to-find wines.
• Plonk offers complimentary shipping on all wine club shipments, while Wine Access provides free shipping on orders of six bottles or more.
• Plonk is very accessible to customers, and Wine Access has a snobbish attitude toward customers.
• Plonk has been consistent over the years, and Wine Access seems to add and remove club options without any planning.